Section 10 NSW – Can You Avoid a Criminal Conviction?

Being charged with a criminal or traffic offence in NSW can be a stressful experience, particularly if you have never been in trouble with the police before.

One of the most common questions people ask is whether they can avoid having a criminal conviction recorded against them.

In some circumstances, the answer is yes.

Section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW) allows a court to find a person guilty of an offence without recording a conviction.

However, obtaining a Section 10 order is never automatic. The outcome depends on the offence, the circumstances of the offending and the person’s individual circumstances.

You can read the full provisions of Section 10 in the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW) on the official NSW legislation website.

1. What Is a Section 10 in NSW?

Section 10 gives a court discretion to deal with certain offences without recording a criminal conviction.

This can be particularly important for people concerned about the consequences of a conviction for their employment, professional registration, travel or future opportunities.

There are several ways a court may deal with a matter under Section 10.

Section 10(1)(a) – Dismissal Without Conviction

The court finds the offence proved but dismisses the charge without recording a conviction.

No further penalty is imposed.

Section 10(1)(b) – Conditional Release Order Without Conviction

The court finds the offence proved but releases the person under a Conditional Release Order (CRO) without recording a conviction.

A CRO can operate for up to two years and requires compliance with certain conditions.

Section 10(1)(c) – Intervention Program

In appropriate circumstances, the court may discharge a person without conviction on the condition that they participate in a relevant intervention program.

This option is subject to statutory requirements.

2. What Does a Judge Consider When Deciding Whether to Grant a Section 10?

Under Section 10(3), the court considers several factors, including:

  • The person’s character, previous history, age, health and mental condition.
  • Whether the offence was trivial in nature.
  • Any extenuating circumstances in which the offence was committed.
  • Any other matter the court considers relevant.

The Judge must also consider the seriousness of the offending and the ordinary principles of sentencing.

A person with no previous criminal history may have stronger prospects of obtaining a Section 10 order, but having a clean record does not guarantee that outcome.

Similarly, a person with previous convictions is not automatically excluded from consideration, although their criminal history may affect the decision.

3. Can You Get a Section 10 for Drink Driving in NSW?

A Section 10 order may be available for certain drink driving offences.

However, the likelihood of obtaining one depends heavily on the circumstances.

The court may consider the blood alcohol reading, the manner of driving, any danger created, previous driving offences and other relevant matters.

A low-range drink driving offence may present different sentencing considerations from a high-range offence.

For high-range drink driving, the courts have emphasised that Section 10 orders should only be made in rare circumstances.

There are also statutory restrictions affecting repeat traffic offenders.

It is therefore important to obtain advice about your particular charge rather than assume that a Section 10 will be available.

4. Can You Get a Section 10 for Drug Driving?

A Section 10 order may also be available for certain drug driving offences in NSW.

For example, a person charged with driving with an illicit drug present in their oral fluid or blood may wish to seek an outcome without conviction.

The Judge will consider the circumstances of the offence, the person’s driving history, any previous offending and the relevant sentencing principles.

Completing a traffic offender education program may be useful in demonstrating insight and steps taken to avoid further offending.

However, completing a course does not automatically entitle someone to a Section 10 order.

5. Can You Get a Section 10 for Assault or Other Criminal Offences?

Section 10 is not limited to traffic offences.

Depending on the relevant legislation and circumstances, it may be considered in matters involving common assault, drug possession, property damage and other criminal offences.

However, the seriousness of the conduct remains important.

For example, an assault involving injury, domestic violence or aggravating circumstances may require greater emphasis on punishment, denunciation and deterrence.

Every case must be considered individually.

6. What Evidence Can Help With a Section 10 Application?

Preparation is often important when seeking a Section 10 order.

Depending on the circumstances, useful material may include:

  • Character references from people who know you well.
  • Evidence of employment and professional responsibilities.
  • Information about family and caring responsibilities.
  • Medical or psychological reports where relevant.
  • Evidence of counselling, rehabilitation or education programs.
  • Evidence of remorse and insight into the offending.
  • Information about the particular consequences a conviction may have.

A solicitor can advise which material is relevant and how it should be presented.

Simply telling the Judge that a conviction would affect your employment or driver’s licence may not be sufficient.

Where possible, the court should be provided with reliable evidence supporting the matters relied upon.

7. Will a Section 10 Mean I Have No Criminal Record?

A Section 10 order means the court has dealt with the offence without recording a conviction.

However, this does not necessarily mean that all information about the charge disappears from police or court records.

A finding of guilt may still be recorded, and particular disclosure obligations may apply depending on the circumstances.

Some legislation also treats a Section 10 order as a conviction for specific purposes.

It is important to obtain advice about the precise consequences, particularly if you hold professional registration or employment requiring criminal history disclosure.

8. Will a Section 10 Save My Driver’s Licence?

For certain NSW traffic offences, a Section 10 order can mean that the court does not impose the disqualification that would otherwise follow a conviction.

Section 31(4) of the Road Transport Act 2013 (NSW) also prevents demerit points being recorded for an offence dealt with under Section 10.

However, there can be other licensing consequences, including administrative suspensions, that require separate consideration.

Section 203 of the Road Transport Act 2013 also restricts the availability of Section 10 for certain repeat traffic offences within a five-year period.

Obtaining advice before attending court is particularly important if your driver’s licence is essential for your employment or family responsibilities.

9. Should You Engage a Solicitor to Apply for a Section 10?

Although you can represent yourself in court, a properly prepared sentencing application may substantially assist the Judge in understanding your circumstances.

A solicitor can review the charge and police facts, advise whether a Section 10 order is realistically available, help assemble supporting documents and make appropriate sentencing submissions.

It is also important to consider whether pleading guilty is the correct course in the first place.

Before preparing a Section 10 application, the prosecution evidence and any possible defence should be considered.

10. Section 10 Applications in Tweed Heads and Northern NSW

Carl Edwards Solicitor has practised law since 1986 and regularly represents clients in criminal and traffic matters before NSW courts.

Based in Tweed Heads, Carl assists clients from Tweed Heads, Coolangatta, the Gold Coast and surrounding Northern Rivers communities with NSW court matters.

If you have been charged with drink driving, drug driving, common assault, drug possession or another criminal offence, obtaining legal advice early can help you understand your options.

Contact Carl Edwards Solicitor to discuss your charge, your personal circumstances and whether an application for a Section 10 order may be appropriate.

For more information about criminal charges and court representation, visit our Criminal Law page.

If you have been charged with drink driving, drug driving or another traffic offence in NSW, you can also read about our Traffic Lawyers services.

This article provides general information about NSW sentencing law and is not a substitute for legal advice tailored to your individual circumstances.