This article was originally published in June 2018 and has since been reviewed and updated to reflect current NSW sentencing law, including the provisions concerning Conditional Release Orders and the circumstances in which a court may deal with an offence without recording a conviction.
The information remains relevant to people facing drink driving, drug driving and other traffic charges in NSW.
Section 10 NSW sentencing laws allow a court, in appropriate circumstances, to deal with certain criminal and traffic offences without recording a conviction. For someone charged with drink driving, drug driving or another traffic offence, understanding when a section 10 order may be available is particularly important.
Being found guilty of a traffic offence does not necessarily mean that the Court will record a criminal conviction against you.
In New South Wales, section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 allows a Court, in appropriate circumstances, to deal with an offence without recording a conviction.
This can be particularly important for someone facing a drink driving charge, drug driving offence or another traffic matter where a conviction may affect their employment, driving licence or future opportunities.
However, a section 10 order is not automatic. The Court must consider the seriousness of the offence and the circumstances of the individual offender.
Section 10 NSW – What Are the Three Types of Orders?
Section 10(1)(a) — Dismissal without conviction
The Court finds the person guilty but dismisses the charge without recording a conviction or imposing further conditions.
This is generally the most favourable section 10 outcome.
Section 10(1)(b) — Conditional Release Order without conviction
The Court deals with the matter without recording a conviction but places the person on a Conditional Release Order (CRO).
A CRO can operate for up to two years and requires compliance with specified conditions. These include not committing another offence. Additional conditions may also be imposed.
Failing to comply with a CRO can have serious consequences, including being brought back before the Court.
Section 10(1)(c) — Intervention program
The Court may discharge a person without conviction on condition that the person enters into an agreement to participate in an applicable intervention program.
This option is directed towards treatment or rehabilitation and is subject to particular statutory requirements.
What does the Court consider before granting a Section 10?
Under section 10(3), the Court considers factors including:
- The person’s character, previous record, age, health and mental condition.
- Whether the offence is of a trivial nature.
- Any extenuating circumstances surrounding the offending.
- Any other matter the Court considers relevant.
In a traffic matter, the Court may also receive evidence concerning the person’s driving history, employment, family responsibilities, rehabilitation and steps taken to reduce the likelihood of reoffending.
A Traffic Offender Intervention Program, references and supporting documentation may assist, depending on the circumstances.
However, a good driving record or the need to retain a licence does not, by itself, guarantee a section 10 order.
Can a Section 10 help you keep your driver’s licence?
For certain traffic offences, avoiding a conviction can also mean avoiding a court-imposed licence disqualification that would otherwise follow a conviction.
However, the position depends on the particular offence and any suspension or other administrative action already taken against your licence.
An existing police or Transport for NSW suspension does not necessarily disappear merely because the Court makes a section 10 order.
There are also statutory restrictions on the availability of section 10 for certain traffic offences.
In particular, section 203 of the Road Transport Act 2013 (NSW) restricts the use of section 10 where a person has received a section 10 outcome for another specified traffic offence within the relevant five-year period.
It is therefore important to obtain advice about both the criminal charge and the separate consequences for your driver’s licence.
Can a Section 10 be obtained for drink driving or drug driving?
A section 10 order may be available for some drink driving and drug driving offences, subject to the statutory restrictions.
The Court will consider the seriousness of the offending, any previous offences, the person’s circumstances and the material presented in mitigation.
There is no guarantee that a section 10 application will succeed. Each case must be assessed on its own facts.
Traffic Law Advice in Tweed Heads
Carl Edwards has 40 years of legal experience, having practised as a solicitor since 1986, and regularly represents clients appearing before the New South Wales Local Court.
If you have been charged with drink driving, drug driving, speeding or another traffic offence, it is worthwhile obtaining advice before your court date.
For further information, visit our Traffic Lawyers page.
Carl Edwards Solicitor — Tweed Heads
Telephone: 0421 196 608
This article provides general information about NSW law. The appropriate outcome in any case depends on the individual circumstances and the applicable legislation.